Fromm Four-Star Highlander Beef, Oats, ‘n Barley® Recipe Review

Quick answer

Fromm Four-Star Highlander Beef, Oats, ‘n Barley® Recipe scores 72/100 (very good), a dry food for dogs of all ages. Fromm has had 2 FDA dog food recalls in the last 5 years. Good: named meat listed first (Beef). Not so good: higher in carbohydrates (about 38.3%). It ranks #16 of 42 dry foods we rate.

Fromm Four-Star Highlander Beef, Oats, ‘n Barley® Recipe
Pack image: Fromm
Fromm

72 / 100Very good

Ranks #16 of 42 dry foods we rate

Scores are most meaningful when compared with other dry foods.


Food type
Dry
Life stage
All Life Stages

Label checked October 2026. How we rate

Our verdict

What we like

  • Named meat listed first: Beef
  • 4 named animal proteins in the top 5 ingredients
  • No artificial colors, preservatives or added sugars
  • Complete and balanced (formulated to AAFCO profiles)

Watch out for

  • Higher in carbohydrates: about 38.3%
  • Recalls in the last 5 years: 0 for this product, 2 other brand recall(s)

Scores come from our published formula. No brand can pay for a score.

Nutrients at a glance

Dry matter basis: water removed so wet and dry foods compare fairly.

30%

Protein

17.8%

Fat

38.3%

Carbs (est.)

MethodProteinFatFiberCarbs
Label (as fed) 10% moisture27% min16% min5.5% max34.5%
Dry matter30%17.8%6.1%38.3%
Share of calories (estimated)26.9%38.7%–34.4%

Carbs aren't listed on dog food labels, so we estimate them from the other values.

Calories: 388 kcal per cup · 3,696 kcal per kg

Score breakdown

Protein12 / 25
Fat10 / 10
Carbohydrates3 / 10
Ingredient quality35 / 35
Nutritional adequacy6 / 10
Recall history6 / 10
Why it scored this way: every check
  • Protein 30.0% (dry matter); full points from 45%.
  • Fat 17.8% (dry matter); full points from 14%.
  • Estimated carbohydrates 38.3% (dry matter); full points at 10% or less, none at 50% or more.
  • First main ingredient is a named animal protein (Beef).
  • 4 named animal protein(s) in the top 5 main ingredients.
  • No unnamed animal sources (every animal ingredient names its species).
  • No artificial colors, artificial preservatives, or added sugars.
  • No plant protein concentrates in top 10.
  • Complete and balanced by formulation (AAFCO nutrient profiles).
  • Recalls in the last 5 years: 0 for this product, 2 other brand recall(s).

Ingredients

Listed by weight before cooking. The first five (in bold) usually make up most of the recipe. How to read a dog food label.

  • Named meat, fish or egg 7
  • Grains and starches 6
  • Vitamins and minerals 29
  1. Beef
  2. Beef Broth
  3. Lamb Meal
  4. Haddock
  5. Whole Oats
  6. Dried Egg Product
  7. Whole Barley
  8. Oatmeal
  9. Potatoes
  10. Pearled Barley
  11. Pumpkin
  12. Dried Tomato Pomace
  13. Chicken Fat (preserved with mixed tocopherols)
  14. Beef Liver
  15. Sweet Potatoes
  16. Salmon Oil (preserved with mixed tocopherols)
  17. Chicken
  18. Cheese
  19. Chicken Liver
  20. Flaxseed
  21. Celery
  22. Carrots
  23. Apples
  24. Broccoli
  25. Potassium Chloride
  26. Choline Chloride
  27. Vitamin E Supplement
  28. Ascorbic Acid
  29. Calcium Carbonate
  30. Riboflavin Supplement
  31. Niacin Supplement
  32. Calcium Pantothenate
  33. Vitamin A Supplement
  34. Vitamin D3 Supplement
  35. Pyridoxine Hydrochloride
  36. Biotin
  37. Vitamin B12 Supplement
  38. Thiamine Mononitrate
  39. Folic Acid
  40. Chicory Root Extract
  41. Salt
  42. Zinc Sulfate
  43. Manganese Sulfate
  44. Ferrous Sulfate
  45. Magnesium Sulfate
  46. Zinc Proteinate
  47. ferrous proteinate
  48. Manganese Proteinate
  49. Copper Sulfate
  50. Magnesium Proteinate
  51. Copper Proteinate
  52. Calcium Iodate
  53. Sorbic Acid (Preservative)
  54. Cranberries
  55. Yucca Schidigera Extract
  56. Taurine
  57. Blueberries
  58. Sodium Selenite
  59. dried Lactobacillus paracasei fermentation product
  60. Dried Lactobacillus reuteri Fermentation Product
  61. Dried Lactobacillus acidophilus Fermentation Product
  62. dried Lactobacillus plantarum fermentation product
AAFCO statement

Fromm Four-Star Nutritionals® Highlander Beef, Oats, ‘n Barley® Recipe Food for Dogs is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles for All Life Stages, including growth of large size dogs (70 lb. or more as an adult).

Recipe changes

No recipe changes found since we started tracking this label in September 2026. All recalls and recipe changes.

How much to feed

For example, a 70 lb adult dog that is spayed or neutered and gets daily walks needs about 1,350 calories a day from food. At 388 kcal per cup, that is about 3 1/8 to 3 7/8 cups of Fromm Four-Star Highlander Beef, Oats, ‘n Barley® Recipe a day. Enter your own dog below.

Fromm recall history

FDA dog food recalls in our records for this brand.

DateBrandWhat happenedApplies to
Aug 21, 2026FrommPotential metal contamination (Turkey Pâté and Diner Classics Milo's Meatloaf Pâté wet dog food) FDA noticeBrand recall
Dec 3, 2025FrommPotential foreign plastic contamination (Bonnihill Farms BeefiBowls Beef Recipe) FDA noticeSpecific product

Get an email if this changes

We'll tell you about FDA recalls and recipe changes for Fromm and every other brand we rate.

Only FDA dog food recalls and recipe changes we've checked. We'll send a confirmation email first. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy policy.

More dry food from Fromm

All Fromm foods, best first

Label information from the manufacturer’s website (source), collected October 2026. Always check the package label, and ask your veterinarian about your own dog’s needs.

Similar foods compared

Other rated dry foods for dogs of all ages with the closest scores. Protein and carbs on a dry matter basis.

FoodScoreProteinCarbskcal per cup
Fromm Four-Star Beef Frittata Veg® Recipe74/10033.3%31.7%399
Fromm Four-Star Highlander Beef, Oats, ‘n Barley® Recipe (this food)72/10030%38.3%388
Purina Pro Plan Puppy Toy Breed Chicken & Rice Formula72/10038.6%27.3%533
Purina Pro Plan Puppy Small Breed Chicken & Rice Formula71/10037.5%28.4%482
Kirkland Signature (Costco) Nature’s Domain Puppy Formula Chicken & Pea70/10030%40.6%414

Want a higher score? The top-rated dry food for dogs of all ages we rate is Taste of the Wild Ancient Prairie Canine Recipe with Roasted Bison & Roasted Venison (79/100). See the full ranking.

Questions about this food

Is Fromm Four-Star Highlander Beef, Oats, ‘n Barley® Recipe grain-free?

No. Its ingredients include grains or grain products: whole oats, whole barley, oatmeal.

How many calories are in Fromm Four-Star Highlander Beef, Oats, ‘n Barley® Recipe?

The label lists 388 kcal per cup and 3,696 kcal per kg.

Has Fromm Four-Star Highlander Beef, Oats, ‘n Barley® Recipe been recalled?

Fromm has had 2 FDA dog food recalls in the last 5 years. We check FDA dog food recall records going back 5 years.

Is Fromm Four-Star Highlander Beef, Oats, ‘n Barley® Recipe complete and balanced?

Yes. The label says: "Fromm Four-Star Nutritionals® Highlander Beef, Oats, 'n Barley® Recipe Food for Dogs is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles for All Life Stages, including growth of large size dogs (70 lb. or more as an adult)."

What is the first ingredient in Fromm Four-Star Highlander Beef, Oats, ‘n Barley® Recipe?

The first ingredient is Beef. Ingredients are listed by weight before cooking.

Why does Fromm Four-Star Highlander Beef, Oats, ‘n Barley® Recipe score 72/100?

It earns 35/35 for ingredients, 12/25 for protein, 10/10 for fat, 3/10 for carbs, 6/10 for nutritional adequacy and 6/10 for recall history. Most points are lost on protein, down 13 points. Why: protein 30.0% on a dry matter basis, with full points from 45%.

Ask your vet about your own dog's needs.

Compare with the best

Is your dog's food safe?

We track FDA recalls and quiet recipe changes for every food we rate. Get a free email when we find one.

Only FDA dog food recalls and recipe changes we've checked. We'll send a confirmation email first. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy policy.

See recalls and recipe changes
Fromm Four-Star Highlander Beef, Oats, ‘n Barley® Recipe 72/100